Writing Helpful Reviews

Some reviews help our panel make more informed decisions about articles submitted to Mathematics Teacher, while others are less helpful. To assist referees in preparing the best article reviews, we offer a copy of an article in its original form, two sample reviews of that article, and a discussion of each review’s strengths and weaknesses.

Article Submission: The Dating Game by Monte Zerger. (Revised article published in February 1998 MT)

Helpful Review

Less Helpful Review